Your Girlfriends are lying to you – Navigating the Culture Wars of the Gender Divide

In my last article, I sought to explore the reasons behind the growing divide between the sexes and proposed ways we might bridge it. Today, I dive deeper into the culture wars, focusing on the dynamics I’ve observed in singlehood and my theories on why they persist.

The Warfare Among Women

One of the most striking dynamics in the dating landscape of 2024 is the often-overlooked competition among women themselves. This phenomenon is ancient, rooted in the evolutionary drive to secure the best mates, yet it persists in modern times. While the ethos of “women supporting women” has become a dominant cultural narrative, particularly with movements like “slay queen” and “girl’s girl” advocacy, the reality often diverges from the ideal.

This supportive culture, while positive in many respects, can sometimes obscure an uncomfortable truth: women may inadvertently undermine one another in the realm of dating and relationships. This phenomenon, often masked as well-intentioned advice, can lead to detrimental outcomes.

The Social Media Effect

Part of this dynamic stems from the atomized hive mind created by social media, particularly platforms like TikTok. For many, especially younger women, the curated and artificial realities of these platforms become a skewed lens through which they view relationships.

Adding to this is the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on socialization during formative years. For Gen Z individuals aged 18–24, the isolation of the pandemic, combined with the influence of social media algorithms and the rise of the “boss babe” culture, has contributed to a heightened skepticism of men and relationships. Against this backdrop, let’s examine some of the problematic advice that women often give one another about dating.

Bad Dating Advice Women Give to Each Other

1. Inconsistent Communication

A common piece of advice popularized by books like The Rules suggests that women should maintain an air of mystery by being inconsistent in their communication. The logic is that being too available will bore men or make them lose interest.

In reality, high-value men—those who are attractive, successful, and have options—are unlikely to invest in someone who plays games. Consistent communication signals interest and maturity, traits that are far more appealing than artificial aloofness.

2. The Guy Must Like the Girl More

Another pervasive myth is that for a relationship to succeed, the man must be more invested than the woman. This notion, often perpetuated by TikTok and online advice, fails under scrutiny.

Consider the “SIMP” archetype—a man who is overly infatuated and invested in a woman who shows little reciprocation. Ask any woman how many of her SIMPs she finds wildly attractive, and the answer will likely be none. True attraction and respect require mutual admiration, not an imbalance in effort or affection.

3. Women Speaking for Other Women

A fascinating trend in modern dating is the tendency for one woman to speak on behalf of another, particularly in social settings. This often happens under the guise of “protecting” a friend who is perceived as too kind or unable to reject unwanted attention.

While the intent may be noble, the implications are significant. Outsourcing decisions about whom to engage with can lead to missed opportunities and perpetuate a dynamic where one friend dominates the other. In relationships, this can result in the man effectively dating not just his partner but her entire social circle, complicating the partnership.

Moving Forward: The Path to Better Advice

The convergence of social media, pandemic-induced isolation, and the “girl’s girl” culture has contributed to a rise in poor dating advice among women. Here’s a reality check for navigating the dating world:

• Consistent Communication: Men value clarity and consistency. Playing games often signals immaturity or disinterest.
• Mutual Investment: Relationships thrive on balanced affection and effort. High-value connections require mutual respect and admiration.
• Autonomy in Decision-Making: Women should feel empowered to make their own choices, free from the overreach of friends or social pressure.

In conclusion, a combination of modern cultural shifts and outdated myths has led to advice that often works against women’s best interests in dating. By fostering a mindset rooted in authenticity and mutual respect, both men and women can navigate the complexities of relationships with greater success.